a-cosmology-group/acg#230

View on GitHub →
#230 What is this giant mysterious ring in the sky?
LifeIsStrangeLifeIsStrange, edited OpenAstrophysics and Physics

So I was browsing bands of the eROSITA, largest ever xray sky survey, and I stumbled upon a gigantic xray ring. This xray ring is

  1. absolutely gigantic
  2. it strikingly is a perfect ring (no deformities), which is a naturally “impossible” shape
  3. it seems to have a high energy source in its center

2024-06-07_22-21

One might wonder wether this is an instrument artifact such as the famous JWST point spread function but I don’t find any other similar artifact which makes it highly unlikely. Moreover we aren’t just seeing a circle, but when we zoom in, we see that the circle is sparse and entirely made of specific point light sources (hence a robust observation). You can look at it by youserlf on the amazing website https://sky.esa.int/esasky/?target=207.37005841753205%20-63.23852487750319&hips=eROSITA-DE+DR1+Band+022+(0.6-2.3+keV)+Count+Image&fov=3.3233545224144536&cooframe=J2000&sci=true&lang=fr enable science mode click on the top left button to manage skys click on the + button browse hips registry search “erosita” on title field select band 0.6-2.3kev (count image) and look for a circle, it is so big you will find it pretty quickly

I am not sure wether this is the giant ring (figure 1) from this paper https://arxiv.org/abs/2012.11754 would be nice if you could confirm the location, honestly it is the most anomalous astrophysical object I have ever seen. coordinates: https://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/sim-coo?&Coord=207.115718597728d-63.234997276912d&CooFrame=FK5&Radius=2&Radius.unit=arcmin edit: yes! this does correspond to the coordinates of a “black hole” (center of the ring) and hence of this 2020 paper! https://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=MAXI+J1348-630+&NbIdent=1&Radius=2&Radius.unit=arcmin&submit=submit+id

Also related are eROSITA (and fermi) bubbles https://arxiv.org/pdf/2012.05840 see Extended Data Fig. 2

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04264

on the topic of rings, there are also the intriguing (but much smaller) ring galaxies (could they constrain MOND/DM?) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_galaxy#/media/File:Hoag’s_object.jpg As for known ring megastructures, there is the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_GRB_Ring and discovered in 2024, the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Ring

note: anyone knows the difference in terminology for a sky survey band between a rate image and a count image? note2: the structure is optically invisible note3: it is invisible in xray bands 2.3-5kev and 0.2-0.6kev, and can be seen in 0.2-2.3, 0.6-2.3 and 1-2kev and it is slighly visible on the full RGB image. the structure is best seen in 0.6-2.3 which probably means it selectively emits in that range (possibly 0.6-2 or 1-2.3)

So the ring is identified but still the question remains, how can such an object be formed? Why is it unique in the observable universe? etc..

2
Comments (2)

It seems this ring transient behaviour “breaks” classical black hole models?

At other stages of the outburst cycle, the behaviour is more unusual, inconsistent with the canonical outburst evolution of black hole transients. In particular, during the hard rise, the apparent inner radius is smaller than in the soft state (and increasing), and the peak colour temperature is higher (and decreasing). https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.11919

edit: ORCs, another ring phenomena https://theconversation.com/wtf-newly-discovered-ghostly-circles-in-the-sky-cant-be-explained-by-current-theories-and-astronomers-are-excited-142812 edit off topic infodump: giant filament with a birkeland current https://arxiv.org/abs/2012.08491 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mrsXHDZHeKE

1👍 1